What difference does ministry make? For many, none. They're not part of so-called organized religion and wish it would go away.
Ministry matters in Tennessee: For many others, though, ministry plays a significant role in their lives in the sense that the clergy person provides significant teaching and care that shape their lives. And it matters in the sense that, as lay persons, they, too participate in ministries that touch people's lives.
I'm happy to be challenged on this point, but I suspect most people in Tennessee at some point in their lives come into the orbit of ministry and are affected by it. It may shape their thinking about issues. It may have saved them from going hungry or being without shelter.
It may also be a painful experience of abuse--sexual, emotional, or otherwise. It could be a force that caused them to love some parts of themselves and hate others, a force that challenged them to be better or an overwhelming force that caused them to buckle under the pressure of trying to be good enough.
Ministry affects those who aren't religious: Even those who are not members of congregations are often affected by ministry. Ministry influences public policy and public policy affects all of us--programs for the poor, Bible bills, abortion regulations, anti-transgender bathroom bills, human trafficking legislation, and many other issues are shaped by the quality and quantity of ministry in a particular state or jurisdiction.
Ministry is going to exist in Tennessee. Public policy, such as it is, is going to exist in Tennessee. And they're going to shape each other. So I contend we all have an interest in the quality of ministry in our state. It is actually a public issue on which the public can and should comment.
Thinking about interpretation is key: Here's an example I used to give when I spoke to groups. Why is it that a student in a senior English class in say, Polk County, is made to sweat bullets interpreting a poem written in American English in the 1950s, but later that night, her youth minister, who has no formal training, cracks open a letter attributed to St. Paul for which we have no original manuscript written in Greek almost 2000 years ago to new urban Christians and this youth minister somehow effortlessly creates life lessons for 21st-century rural Southern teenagers?
And yet that happens EVERY WEEK in Tennessee with thousands of people shaping their moral and political views. I could just as easily have chosen an example about sermons or any other kind of ministry, but you get the point. People in Tennessee have been shaped to believe that it's hard to read a poem, but that anyone can interpret and apply the Bible. And, gosh, people apply the strangest passages to the oddest issues. Consider Rep. Eddie Smith's use of the Cain and Abel story to justify his position on guns.
Our challenge is to show the impact of the practice of ministry in such a way that we can reshape it. We should scrutinize it. We should expect more of it. We should expect the best because it affects all of us, regardless of our personal religious views.
LGBT people and our allies, religious or not, in particular have an interest in the quality of ministry in our state because we are all too aware of the negative impact it has had on our community. But the negative history is not the whole story, nor is it destiny. Let's use our voices to make it better.
Yesterday Franklin Graham, son of the legendary evangelist Billy Graham, was in Nashville leading a prayer rally of thousands outside the Capitol.
By all news accounts, his remarks included listing marriage equality as one of our country's evils, on par with racism.
There's no way to know how many of those in attendance agreed with all of his positions on every issue. But there was no rebuttal. I might add that most of the news accounts didn't provide time for other views either.
How many times do we remind ourselves "We've got more work to do?" But it's true.
We have more work to do engaging the media on the issue of the separation of religion and discrimination because there are many people in Tennessee who would like to see that kind of divorce.
We have to engage those on the other side.
If you haven't already, sign the statement on the separation of religion and discrimination. Let's reshape the conversation in Tennessee.
After working with allies the entire legislative session, especially the American Counseling Association and many counselors in Tennessee, to defeat HB1840, we had hoped for a veto. We know the Governor carefully considered his decision, but the reality we now face is that counselors will be able to discriminate against clients based on the counselor’s principles. We continue to worry particularly about rural LGBT people who may not have adequate resources for counseling in their communities.
Counseling Unconditionally: To address the need for counseling across the state, we are launching Counseling Unconditionally today. This initiative allows counselors, therapists, psychologists, psychiatrists, and social workers to identify themselves as practitioners who will not turn away clients simply based on their values and principles. Those interested may sign up at http://tnep.nationbuilder.com/counseling_unconditionally . We know that the vast majority of professionals are eager to help everyone who walks through their door. Their compassion and commitment to ethical standards of care can help repair some of the damage this legislation has caused. It will take legislation or a court order to do the rest.
UT-Knoxville diversity: Please, continue to share the petition urging the Governor to veto the bill that strips funds from the diversity office at the University of Tennessee-Knoxville. Here is the link so you can take action.
We are grateful for all your work.
Yesterday The Tennessean reported that Governor Haslam has not ruled out using his veto pen again. Speaking after legislators adjourned for the year, he said, "They have a constitutional responsibility and we do too."
There's still a chance, which we means we have to do all we can to push for a veto of the Counseling Discrimination bill and the effort to take funds away from the University of Tennessee-Knoxville's diversity office.
TAKE ACTION EVEN IF YOU DON'T LIVE IN TENNESSEE:
1. Call or Tweet the Governor asking him to veto HB1840 because it is bad for the counseling profession and bad for clients. Tweet using @BillHaslam and #VetoHB1840. You can call and leave a message at 615-741-2001. When you have called or Tweeted, let us know at this link.
2. Sign the petition urging the Governor to veto the bill taking funds away from UT-Knoxville's diversity office at this link.
3. If you've already done both, consider forwarding the email to friends.
Thank you for fighting so hard during this tough legislative session.
Separation of Church and state--it's a time honored phrase or at least a paraphrase that comes from the founders of our country.
Many of us like the phrase because it is the right idea, indeed, the correct interpretation of the law, but it doesn't do the work we need it to do in a state like Tennessee.
Many social conservatives know that the phrase never appears in the Constitution itself. They also know that some states had established religions into the 19th Century. Yes, Massachusetts had state supported religion until 1833! And in Tennessee many of them also know that over 50% of the population is Evangelical Protestant. On top of that, I think what religious social conservatives hear when we say "separation of Church and state" is that we're trying to keep Christians out of politics.
And maybe some people do wish that. What I hope we mean when we use the phrase is that we oppose enshrining a particular/majority religion or any religion in law. I hope we mean that law ought to be based on a sense of the common good and the practical needs of the people based on reason and evidence. And how about science, too!
Here's the fact we have to contend with. If you believe in democracy, that means that in Tennessee Evangelical Protestants ARE going to shape the laws of this state. There's just no avoiding it. There are thankfully constitutional limits, but the influence is going to be there for quite some time.
Our task is to shift the discussion to the use of religion to promote discrimination. That strikes me as something that people who are religious and non-religious can talk about together. The lawyers and the judges can and should guide us on the boundaries between religion and government. But we can all, whether we're specialists or not, talk more about the place of discrimination in religion.
I don't think we have to accept the phrase "That's just what I believe" when it comes to using religion to justify discrimination in the public square or in a private business. When actions inspired by your religious beliefs have a public impact, then we actually have a duty to discuss it.
It's the separation of religion and discrimination where we can change the conversation. It recognizes that separation of Church and state isn't enough. If we succeeded in separating Church and state and religion was still being used to promote discrimination, people would continue to suffer.
If you agree, consider endorsing the statement.
And if these issues interest you, consider checking out Jennifer Sheridan's new film project.
The anti-transgender student bathroom bill is personal to me. As a trans man and a recent graduate of Middle Tennessee State University, one of the schools that would be affected by this legislation, I'm outraged.
I have been to Legislative Plaza several times to work against this bill, to tell my story and the story of friends across the state. I have organized against it in Murfreesboro. Sometimes legislators have a breakthrough, sometimes they don't. But I am not deterred because I know that this bill will make life Hell for transgender and gender non-conforming students around the state.
I'm asking you to sign one more petition, regardless of whether you live in Tennessee, urging Governor Haslam to keep listening to those opposed to the bill. It will be part of a multi-organization petition drop next week.
Please, speak out now while there is still time to beat this bill.
TEP Rutherford County Chair
Contact: Chris Sanders, (615) 390-5252 and email@example.com
Nashville, TN--The Tennessee Equality Project condemns House passage of HB1840, also known as Hate Bill 1840 and the Counseling Discrimination bill. We call on Governor Bill Haslam to veto the bill. Citizens can join the call for a veto at this link.
By putting the focus on counselors instead of clients, the bill damages the counseling profession and puts vulnerable clients at risk. We are particularly concerned about rural LGBT people who already have limited access to affirming mental health services.
Opposed by over 50 Tennessee clergy, the bill does not represent the religious freedom it purports to protect.
An anti-bullying amendment that would have protected minors who are victims of bullying was stripped from the bill during a House Health Committee meeting. View TEP's video on the anti-bullying amendment at this link.
By passing a religious refusal bill, the Legislature has opened the door to discrimination in Tennessee and our state could experience the same national wrath that Indiana, North Carolina, and Mississippi are now facing.
TEP thanks the American Counseling Association, the many Tennessee counseling associations, and those state legislators who opposed the bill. In particular, we are grateful to Sen. Jeff Yarbro and Rep. John Ray Clemmons for offering amendments that generated important debate about the bill in an effort to protect the most vulnerable Tennesseans from its consequences.
The Family Action Council, the organization lobbying for the counseling discrimination and the anti-transgender student bathroom bill, is drawing parallels to the Civil War. It's stunning really.
Consider this passage in their April 1 post:
I don’t know how this new “war” will be resolved, but I don’t think it will have to be resolved in the same was as the earlier one. I could be wrong, but I sense there are a lot of people down South who would not mind if the liberals from up North and out West took the advice of their governors and Hollywood moguls, respectively, and decided to stay where they are. The ones among them who want to live in a place that has enough common sense to keep men out of women’s restrooms will just keep migrating to the South.
Now we know why they're fighting so hard against us. They are trying to preserve a South that never was, a South without LGBT people or those who support us. Who even says things like "stay where they are" these days?
There is another South that you and I know. It's a South where mothers testify at Legislative Plaza for their transgender children and transgender students themselves tell legislators about their lives. It's a South where same-sex couples are at last able to protect themselves and their children through marriage. It's a South where clergy are beginning to speak out against hate, where they are resisting the use of religion to keep others down.
I'll take that South and I know you will, too. It will take work to build it as the hateful structures continue to tumble down.
Win or lose this week in the Legislature, we are going to prevail because love wins. Help us move the message of love and acceptance at this link with your support.
Tennessee clergy are speaking out against HB1840, known as Hate Bill 1840, with the following statement:
"As faith leaders and clergy serving people in Tennessee, we urge the Tennessee House of Representatives to reject House Bill 1840, which allows counselors to turn clients away based on the counselor's religious beliefs. Those seeking counseling deserve the highest standard of care and we believe the American Counseling Association's code of ethics provides that standard."
Rev. Emily Reeves Grammer, Nashville
Rev. Dr. Bruce W. Spangler, Knoxville
Rev. Michael Williams, Nashville
Rev. Adam Kelchner, Nashville
Rev. Tim Kobler, Knoxville
Rev. Nancy Speas Hill, Franklin
Bishop Melvin G. Talbert, retired, The United Methodist Church, Hermitage
Rev. Allison Hancock, Memphis
Rev. Deven Hazelwood, Johnson City
Rev. Pamela Hawkins, Nashville
Rev. Eric Posa, Memphis
Rabbi Josh Barton, Nashville
Rev. William (Will) Berger, Franklin
Rev. Laura Bogle, Maryville
Rev. Bryan Currie, Nashville
Jon Coffee, ministerial candidate, Knoxville
Rev. Cynthia Andrews-Looper, Memphis
Rev. V. Jill Sizemore, Knoxville
Rev. Ken Carroll, Chattanooga
Rev. Andrew B. Ward, Goodlettsville
Rev. Orisha Bowers, Memphis
Rev. Paul Slentz, Nashville
Rev. Steve Wolf, Clarksville
Rev. William Warren, Germantown
Rev. John A Smith, Nashville
Rev. Byron Forester, Memphis
Rev. Steven Shelton, Bartlett
Rev. Lisa Anderson, Memphis
Rev. Mark Brown, Memphis
Rev. Dr. Gillian Marie Klee, Memphis
Rev. Ruth Lovell Bradham, Cordova
Rev. Anne Fraley, Lebanon
Rev. James C. Pappas III, Fayetteville
Rev. Dorothy Chatham Hartzog, retired Episcopal priest, Clarksville
Rev. Mark C. Pafford, Cookeville
Rev. Michael Alford, Nashville
Rev. Lisa Gwock, Nashville
Rev. Joey Reed, OSL, Jackson
Rev. Kira Schlesinger, Lebanon
Pastor Tommy Artist, Johnson City
Bishop Charles Headley, Jefferson City
Rev. Cheryl Cornish, Memphis
Rev. John Burruss, Memphis
Barney Self, Ed.D., LMFT, Pastoral Counseling Minister and President of TNAMFT, Forest Hills
Bishop Patrick Potts, Johnson City
Rabbi Shana Goldstein Mackler, Nashville
Rev. Eric S. Greenwood, Jr., Nashville
Rev. Eugene J. Bolton, Nashville
Cantor Tracy L. Fishbein, Nashville
Rev. Greg Bullard, Madison
Rev. Renee Dillard, Memphis
Rev. Kevin Mitchell, Murfreesboro
If you are a member of the clergy serving people in Tennessee and would like to sign the statement, contact us with your name and city at firstname.lastname@example.org .
A guest post by Brendon Holloway, TEP Rutherford County Committee Chair
Transgender Day of Visibility is about more than just being visible; it is about fighting for social justice for transgender individuals in the community and at state and federal levels. It is about being visible on a social and political platform. It is about making your voice heard. How can a transgender person make a difference in politics? Be visible. Be visible in your community (if you can, of course) and be visible to your elected officials.
During the holiday season, a Republican representative from my hometown was hinting at proposing an anti-trans bathroom bill. In response, I emailed him and we met for coffee the day after Christmas. He saw me for who I was and he respected that. For the first time, he sat down with a transgender man and heard the other side of the story. After meeting up several times, he completely backed away from the anti-trans bathroom bill and admitted that he had no idea of the hardships trans people face. He said that he would have never understood a trans person’s perspective if we hadn’t met for coffee. I understand that most politicians aren’t as open-minded as he was, but sometimes being visible and speaking up will open ones mind.
Shortly before this, I met up with my mayor regarding an LGBTQ rally. We spoke about having a rally at the courthouse in Murfreesboro and what legal steps I should take to be able to do so. Although he wasn’t open to the idea of an indoor rally, he said an outdoor rally would be appropriate. If I didn’t speak with him professionally and let my personal identity show, then I’m not sure if he would’ve been so receptive. When it comes to lawmakers and elected officials, sometimes they just need to see that you are a real person. The same goes for the pronoun issue at the University of Tennessee – Knoxville. When UTK’s Office for Diversity and Inclusion posted a gender-neutral pronoun chart, our lawmakers immediately jumped on it. Without hesitation, I went to Legislative Plaza and met with a few senators who would be hearing the issue. Although their minds didn’t instantly change, they were open to discussing the issue and learning more about it and offered to meet with me later in the week. Engaging with elected officials is important and being visible can make a difference politically.
Transgender Day of Visibility is a day of empowerment for our trans brothers, sisters, friends, and family. Today is a day for us to stand up and show that we can make a difference, too. I have been spending much of my time on Capitol Hill in Nashville for the past year trying to make a difference in the LGBTQ community, especially for the trans community. I’ve changed minds, hearts, and learned how to be a political activist while also staying true to my identity and who I am. Today is a day for us to be recognized but every day is a day for us to be visible.